Argument Analysis & Strengthening

Critique and strengthen my argument.

My argument: [paste your complete argument]

Context:

• Who I'm arguing to: [audience - their existing beliefs, biases]
• Purpose: [persuade/defend/refute/explore]
• Stakes: [what happens if I win/lose this argument]

What I need you to do:

1. Identify logical gaps or fallacies (where my reasoning breaks down)
2. Flag weak evidence (claims that need better support)
3. Surface counterarguments (strongest objections someone could make)
4. Suggest how to strengthen weak points (better evidence, reasoning)
5. Provide an improved version (maintaining my core position)

Be honest about:

• Where my argument is genuinely weak
• Whether my conclusion follows from my premises
• Assumptions I'm making that might not hold

Success criteria: My argument withstands scrutiny and I can respond confidently to challenges.